Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
D1653-13 – Standard Test Method Technical Guide
🔬 Scope and Significance
Standard D1653-13 (Reapproved 2021) specifies two test methods—the Dry Cup Method (Method A) and the Wet (Payne) Cup Method (Method B)—for determining the water vapor transmission (WVT) rate of films made from paints, varnishes, lacquers, and other organic coatings. The films may be tested as free-standing films prepared in accordance with Practice D4708, or as coatings applied directly to a porous substrate. This standard is approved for use by agencies of the U.S. Department of Defense.
The standard cautions users against directly comparing results obtained from different test methods or different test conditions. The selected method must closely approach the intended conditions of use to provide meaningful data for material selection or quality assurance. A related general test method, ASTM E96, provides a broader approach and should be considered when other materials are involved.
⚠️ Precision and Bias: The standard notes that rapid, instrumental methods for measuring WVT exist but explicitly cautions that no side-by-side comparison studies have been conducted to confirm the precision and accuracy of these instruments relative to the official Dry Cup and Wet Cup methods described in D1653 and E96.
⚙️ Test Method A (Dry Cup) vs. Method B (Wet Cup)
Both methods measure the steady-state flow of water vapor across a film under a controlled vapor pressure gradient. The critical difference is the environment established inside the test cup, which dictates the direction and magnitude of the driving force.
| 🟦 Feature | 🎯 Method A: Dry Cup | 🎯 Method B: Wet (Payne) Cup |
|---|---|---|
| Inside Cup Condition | Desiccant (~0% RH) | Distilled Water (~100% RH) |
| Outside Cup Condition | Controlled humidity environment (e.g., 50% RH per ASTM E104) | Controlled dry environment (e.g., 50% RH per ASTM E104) |
| Measured Data | Weight gain over time (water vapor absorbed by desiccant) | Weight loss over time (water vapor escaping through film) |
| Typical Application | Simulating a coating facing exterior moisture while the interior remains dry | Simulating a coating in direct contact with liquid water or constantly high humidity |
In both methods, the specimen is sealed over the cup opening and placed in a precisely controlled chamber. The steady-state flow is determined through periodic weighings. Agreement should not be expected between results from different methods; the test that most closely matches the service environment should be selected.
📊 Key Measured Properties: WVT and WVP
Results from the test are reported as either the Water Vapor Transmission Rate (WVT) or the Water Vapor Permeance (WVP). Understanding the definitions and standard units laid out in the terminology section is critical for accurate reporting.
| 🟦 Property | 📐 Definition | 📏 Standard Inch-Pound Unit | ⚡ Equivalent SI Unit |
|---|---|---|---|
| WVT (Water Vapor Transmission Rate) | Steady vapor flow per unit time through unit area between two specific surfaces under specific conditions | grains/(ft²·h) | g/(m²·24h) |
| WVP (Water Vapor Permeance) | WVT induced by a unit vapor pressure difference (WVP = WVT / Δp) | grains/(ft²·h·inHg) [called a perm] | g/(m²·24h·mmHg) [called a metric perm] |
Conversion factors between the inch-pound and SI unit systems are provided in detail within Sections 13.2.1.2 and 13.2.2.2 of the standard. Film thickness must be measured in accordance with Test Method D1005, and films should be prepared to a uniform thickness according to Practices D823.
💡 Selecting the Right Approach: For coatings acting as a vapor barrier on the interior (dry side) of a building assembly, the Dry Cup Method (A) is appropriate. For coatings intended for submersed service or constant wetting, the Wet Cup Method (B) provides a more realistic assessment of field performance.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
🔍 What is the primary difference between ASTM D1653 and ASTM E96?
D1653 is specifically written for organic coating films (paints, varnishes, lacquers) and includes specific guidance for testing free films and films on porous substrates. E96 is a more general standard applicable to a wide variety of sheet materials.
⚡ Why can’t I compare Dry Cup results directly with Wet Cup results?
The vapor pressure gradient across the film is fundamentally different between the two methods. The standard explicitly states (Section 1.3.3) that agreement should not be expected between different methods or test conditions. The test must match the end-use exposure.
📌 Can I test the coating directly on a substrate, or must I use a free film?
Both options are valid and explicitly outlined in the scope. Testing on a porous substrate often yields data more representative of in-service performance, whereas free films (prepared per D4708) allow isolation of the pure coating material’s barrier properties.
💡 What specific physical unit does a “perm” represent?
A “perm” is the accepted inch-pound unit of water vapor permeance (WVP). It represents the passage of 1 grain of water vapor through 1 square foot of material per hour, driven by a differential vapor pressure of 1 inch of mercury.