Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
Understanding Hydraulic Excavator and Backhoe Digging Forces: A Guide to SAE J1179-2008
🛠️ Overview and Scope of SAE J1179-2008
The standard SAE J1179-2008, titled ‘Hydraulic Excavator and Backhoe Digging Forces,’ provides a uniform method for determining the digging forces of hydraulic excavators and backhoes. It applies to both crawler-mounted and rubber-tire-mounted machines, with or without outriggers, as identified in SAE J1116 and defined in SAE J/ISO 6165. Initially issued in 1977, it was cancelled in March 2008 and superseded by the international standard ISO 6015. Despite its cancellation, the principles outlined remain widely used in the industry for calculating and verifying digging forces.
The key purpose of this standard is to ensure consistency in how manufacturers determine and publish digging force values, enabling accurate comparisons between machines and attachments. It establishes definitions for working circuit pressure and holding circuit pressure, and specifies conditions for calculating maximum digging forces.
🔍 Defining Maximum Digging Forces
Per SAE J1179, working circuit pressure is the nominal pressure applied to a specific circuit by the pump(s), while holding circuit pressure is the maximum static pressure in a circuit limited by a relief valve at a flow no greater than 10% of the circuit rated flow. Maximum digging forces are calculated by applying working circuit pressure to the cylinder(s) providing the digging force, without exceeding holding circuit pressure in any other circuit. Critically, the weight of components and friction are excluded to obtain theoretical maximum forces.
The standard defines three specific digging forces:
| Force | Description | Positioning |
|---|---|---|
| Maximum Bucket Tangential Force (V) | Digging force generated by the bucket cylinder(s), tangent to the arc of radius C (distance from bucket pivot to cutting edge). | Bucket positioned to obtain the maximum output moment from the bucket cylinder(s) and connecting linkage. |
| Maximum Arm/Dipperstick Force (W) | Digging force generated by the arm/dipperstick cylinder(s), tangent to the arc of radius B. | Arm/dipperstick positioned for maximum output moment; bucket positioned as per bucket tangential force condition. |
| Maximum Telescoping Boom Crowd Force (U) | Digging force generated by the telescoping boom cylinder acting on a line parallel to the boom. This applies only to telescoping booms, not extendable arms/dippersticks. | Independent of bucket position. |
It is important to note that the force calculations exclude component weight and friction, and they assume ideal positioning to maximize hydraulic cylinder moment.
⚠️ Verification, Conditions, and Design Insights
SAE J1179 specifies several conditions for calculating and publishing digging forces:
- Specified bucket linkage configuration must be used unless otherwise noted.
- Maximum digging forces are quoted with a specific bucket.
- Adjustable arm/dippersticks must be at the minimum extension position unless otherwise noted.
- Additional digging forces may be specified separately for different buckets or equipment.
- The manufacturer must verify published hydraulic digging forces by actual tests. Test values for any new machine must exceed 95% of the published digging force values. For this verification, the boom, arm/dipperstick, and bucket are to be positioned to minimize the effect of component weight on force measurements.
⚠️ Common Mistake: A frequent error in digging force calculations is using holding circuit pressure instead of working circuit pressure. Always apply working circuit pressure as defined in SAE J1179 for the circuit providing the force. Additionally, remember that theoretical calculations should never include component weight or friction—the standard separates these to produce a consistent, comparable maximum force value.
🛠️ Design Insight: The requirement that adjustable arm/dippersticks be set at minimum extension to maximize force is a deliberate design choice. Engineers should note that if an extended position is used, it will likely reduce the effective digging force. Also, because published values must be verifiable within 95% on a new machine, design margins should account for manufacturing tolerances and test conditions.
Another crucial design insight is that the standard emphasizes consistent bucket linkage configuration for comparability. Changing the linkage can significantly alter the mechanical advantage and thus the calculated force. For design engineers, this standard provides a clear, repeatable method for rating machine capabilities.
Frequently Asked Questions
How is the maximum bucket tangential force calculated?
The force is calculated by applying working circuit pressure to the bucket cylinder(s) while positioning the bucket to achieve the maximum output moment from the cylinder and linkage. The resulting force is tangent to the arc radius from the bucket pivot to the cutting edge. Weight and friction are excluded.
What distinguishes working circuit pressure from holding circuit pressure?
Working circuit pressure is the nominal pump pressure supplied to the circuit during operation. Holding circuit pressure is a static pressure limit set by a relief valve at low flow (≤10% rated flow). In digging force calculations, you use working circuit pressure for the active cylinder circuit, but you must ensure that no other circuit exceeds its holding circuit pressure.
Why must published digging forces be verified by test?
Verification ensures that the theoretical values are achievable in practice. The standard requires that any new machine achieve at least 95% of the published force values under test conditions that minimize weight effects. This guarantees that performance claims are realistic and reliable for customers.
Can I specify digging forces for different attachments?
Yes. The standard allows additional digging forces to be specified separately for different available buckets or equipment. This flexibility accommodates the fact that different attachments will yield different force values due to variations in geometry and mass.
In summary, SAE J1179-2008 (now superseded by ISO 6015) remains a foundational reference for hydraulic excavator and backhoe digging force determination. Its definitions, calculation methods, and verification requirements ensure that engineers and customers have a consistent basis for comparing machine performance.
