Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
Standardized Test Method for Suction/Blower Fan Performance in Self-Propelled Sweepers (SAE J1792-2-2015)
For self-propelled sweepers that rely entirely on pneumatic conveyance to collect and transfer sweepings, the suction/blower fan is the heart of the system. SAE J1792-2-2015 provides a rigorous, repeatable test method to measure and disclose the performance of these fans. This article explains the standard’s approach, from test setup to data correction, offering practical insights for engineers and technicians seeking reliable fan performance comparisons.
Overview and Purpose
SAE J1792-2-2015 establishes a test method and a format for presenting the performance of suction/blower fans used in vacuum and regenerative air street sweepers (as defined in SAE J2130-1). The measured performance considers the air volume movement versus the static depression (negative pressure) developed by the fan across a spectrum of operating conditions. The method is designed to disclose or compare particular operating performance criteria under similar conditions, enabling fair benchmarking between machines or fan configurations.
Test Procedure and Setup
The test begins by preparing the machine in its optimum running condition according to the operator’s manual. Key preparation steps include:
- Cleaning or removing hopper filter meshes and all air ducts to ensure they are free from debris.
- Sealing wander hoses, drain hoses, and any other openings that could cause air leakage.
- Removing the suction pick-up nozzle and flexible conduit, then substituting them with a test duct of known cross-section (see standard Figures 1 and 2).
The test duct is fitted with a blanking mechanism (e.g., adjustable plate) to progressively restrict airflow. Two small holes at 90° are provided midway along the duct for pitot tube insertion.
During the test, engine and fan speed must remain constant; a digital tachometer connected to the engine or fan is preferred. Ambient temperature and barometric pressure are recorded before and after the test pass to enable corrections to standard conditions (20°C, 1013 mb).
The pitot tube, marked with six radial positions (based on duct internal diameter), is inserted with the probe pointing into the airstream within 5° of the duct axis. Velocity head readings are taken at all twelve positions (six per hole). The average velocity head from these readings is used to calculate air velocity and volume. Static pressure in the fan eye is recorded both before and after each test pass. This process is repeated with the duct inlet progressively blanked (moved nearer to the ground) to map the fan’s performance curve from free air to near-shutoff.
⚠️ Common Mistakes to Avoid
– Improper pitot tube alignment (angle >5° off axis) or using incorrect traverse positions.
– Neglecting to seal wander hoses or drain openings, causing air leakage.
– Omitting corrections for ambient temperature, barometric pressure, or duct static depression.
– Recording static pressure only before or after the test pass instead of both.
These errors can render test results invalid or incomparable.
– Improper pitot tube alignment (angle >5° off axis) or using incorrect traverse positions.
– Neglecting to seal wander hoses or drain openings, causing air leakage.
– Omitting corrections for ambient temperature, barometric pressure, or duct static depression.
– Recording static pressure only before or after the test pass instead of both.
These errors can render test results invalid or incomparable.
Calculations, Corrections, and Results
To ensure data is comparable across different ambient conditions, three corrections are applied to the velocity head measurement: temperature correction (to 20°C), barometric pressure correction (to 1013 mb), and duct static depression correction (to standard density). The corrected velocity is then used to compute air velocity in the duct and the volume of conveying air (m³/s or cfm).
The necessary measurement parameters and their purposes are summarized below:
| Parameter | Measurement Device | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Velocity head (mm H₂O) | Pitot tube + manometer | Calculate air velocity and volume flow |
| Static depression in fan eye (mm H₂O) | Manometer | Define fan performance curve (pressure vs. flow) |
| Ambient temperature (°C) | Thermometer | Correct air density to standard 20°C |
| Barometric pressure (mb) | Barometer | Correct to standard 1013 mb sea level |
| Fan speed (rpm) | Tachometer | Ensure constant speed during test |
The corrected air flow volume versus the negative static pressure in the fan eye is then presented in both tabular form (as shown in the standard’s Figure 4) and graphically (Figure 5). The graphical format makes it easy to compare performance curves for different fans or operating conditions.
🔍 Engineering Design Insight
The standard emphasizes that all non-essential openings must be sealed and ducts clean to ensure the measured performance is solely from the fan. This avoids misleading results from leakage or blockage. The use of a pitot traverse with multiple radial positions accounts for non-uniform velocity profiles, while corrections for temperature and pressure allow direct comparison of results obtained under different ambient conditions. Such rigor is essential for validating fan selection or diagnosing performance issues in the field.
The standard emphasizes that all non-essential openings must be sealed and ducts clean to ensure the measured performance is solely from the fan. This avoids misleading results from leakage or blockage. The use of a pitot traverse with multiple radial positions accounts for non-uniform velocity profiles, while corrections for temperature and pressure allow direct comparison of results obtained under different ambient conditions. Such rigor is essential for validating fan selection or diagnosing performance issues in the field.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Why is it necessary to clean or remove the hopper filter meshes before testing?
Dirty filters can restrict airflow, giving the impression that the fan underperforms. Cleaning or removing them ensures that only the fan’s inherent performance is measured, not the effect of a clogged filter.
2. How is the pitot traverse performed to get an accurate average velocity head?
The pitot tube is inserted through two perpendicular holes in the duct, and readings are taken at six equal-area radial positions in each hole (total 12 readings). The average of these 12 readings compensates for asymmetry in the velocity profile, yielding a reliable mean velocity head.
3. What corrections are applied to normalize results to standard conditions?
Three corrections are applied: temperature (to 20°C), barometric pressure (to 1013 mb), and duct static depression (to correct air density to standard conditions). These corrections ensure that results from tests performed on different days or locations can be directly compared.
4. Why is it important to record static pressure both before and after each test pass?
The static pressure in the fan eye can drift slightly during traversal due to changes in flow or fan speed. Recording it before and after and averaging the two values improves accuracy and accounts for any minor variations.
By following SAE J1792-2-2015, engineers and technicians can obtain consistent, defensible performance data for suction/blower fans in self-propelled sweepers, supporting better design, troubleshooting, and fleet management decisions.
