Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
SAE J1737-2019: Measuring Hydrocarbon Losses from Fuel Tubes and Assemblies
Understanding the Test Procedure
The SAE J1737-2019 standard establishes a recirculation-based test procedure to measure evaporative hydrocarbon losses from fuel system components such as tubes, hoses, fittings, and assemblies. This method provides engineers with a realistic simulation of in-service fuel exposure, essential for evaluating compliance with emissions regulations.
🛠️ Design Insight: The recirculation method captures both permeation through the material and leakage at joints, making it suitable for complete assemblies as well as individual components.
The key apparatus includes: a fuel container with inert gas pressurization (typically nitrogen), a recirculation pump, a test cell housing the specimen, a heater to control fuel temperature, and a collection device with activated charcoal to capture hydrocarbon vapors. Carrier gas sweeps the test cell to transport vapors to the collection media.
| Parameter | Typical Requirement |
|---|---|
| Temperature | Controlled to simulate underhood or ambient conditions (e.g., 23°C, 40°C, or 60°C) |
| Fuel Type | Specified test fuel (e.g., Fuel C or CM15) to represent gasoline permeation |
| Pressure | Maintained at test level using inert gas, typically 14-34 kPa (2-5 psi) |
| Wall Thickness | Actual wall thickness of component; results often normalized to thickness |
| Moisture Content | Must be controlled to avoid affecting permeation rates |
| Test Duration | Until steady-state condition is achieved (often 5-10 days for new materials) |
Critical Considerations for Accurate Results
Obtaining reliable hydrocarbon loss measurements requires strict adherence to control conditions and careful interpretation of data.
⚠️ Common Mistake: Failing to achieve true steady-state before recording measurements. The standard requires that the loss rate be constant over a specified period (e.g., 24 hours) to be considered at equilibrium.
Steady-State Determination: The time to reach steady-state varies widely depending on material, construction, and temperature. The procedure recommends periodic weight loss measurements and plotting to confirm when the rate becomes linear. Using weight loss techniques or SHED units can help verify steadiness.
2019 Update – Low Emission Testing: The current revision of SAE J1737 introduces an alternative test method for components with very low emission levels. Existing gravimetric methods lack sensitivity for these new materials. The alternative approach uses a modified SHED (Sealed Housing Evaporative Determination) to detect minute mass losses, ensuring the standard remains relevant for evolving fuel system technologies.
Other Factors: Variations in wall thickness, construction (e.g., multi-layer hoses), and environmental humidity can significantly affect permeation. Engineers should normalize results by thickness and construction type and report conditions with the data.
Frequently Asked Questions
How is steady-state determined?
Steady-state is confirmed when the weight loss per unit time becomes constant. Typically, the specimen is weighed at regular intervals (e.g., every 24 hours) and once the loss rate varies by less than 5% over three consecutive measurements, equilibrium can be assumed.
What is the low emission alternative method in the 2019 revision?
The alternative method uses a SHED enclosure with a sensitive hydrocarbon analyzer to measure the accumulation of fuel vapors in the enclosure over time. This allows detection of losses that are too small for weight-based techniques.
How should test results be reported?
Results should include the test conditions (temperature, fuel type, pressure), specimen dimensions (wall thickness, length, ID/OD), and the steady-state loss rate in units of mass per time (e.g., g/day) or per length (e.g., g/m·day). Normalizing to wall thickness is recommended for comparison.
Can the test be used for assemblies with multiple materials?
Yes, the recirculation test can evaluate complete assemblies. However, interpretation may require separate testing of individual components to isolate contributions from different materials or connections.
🔍 Conclusion: SAE J1737-2019 provides a rigorous framework for measuring hydrocarbon losses from fuel system components. Understanding its methodology, controlling test conditions, and being aware of the 2019 update are essential for accurate and meaningful emissions testing.
