Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
SAE J1718: Measuring Hydrogen Gas from Electric Vehicle Battery Charging โ Procedures and Insights
SAE J1718-2008 is a surface vehicle recommended practice that provides a standardized procedure for measuring gaseous hydrogen emissions from the aqueous battery systems of battery-powered passenger cars and light trucks during charging. 🛠️ This article explores the key aspects of this standard, its test requirements, and the reasons for its eventual cancellation.
Purpose and Scope of SAE J1718
The primary purpose of SAE J1718 is to determine the concentration of hydrogen gas generated when an electric vehicle with an aqueous battery is charged in a residential garage. The test results help assess whether forced air ventilation is required to maintain safety according to NFPA 30 guidelines, which define adequate ventilation as sufficient to prevent vapor-air mixtures from exceeding one-fourth of the lower flammable limit (LFL). The scope covers both normal charging conditions and abnormal conditions, such as single point failures in the charging control subsystem that could significantly increase gassing. It also specifies temperature extremes (43°C and -18°C) to simulate worst-case garage environments.
Note: SAE J1718 applies exclusively to aqueous battery systems, such as lead-acid or nickel-metal hydride vented batteries. It does not cover sealed battery systems or fuel cell vehicles.
Key Test Requirements and Engineering Insights
The standard defines a detailed test setup and procedure. Below is a summary of critical parameters:
| Parameter | Requirement |
|---|---|
| Test Enclosure | Internal dimensions 3 x 6 x 2.6 m (10 x 20 x 8.5 ft), with low hydrogen permeation materials (e.g., polyvinyl fluoride sheet). One side should be a flexible blow-out panel. |
| Temperature Extremes | Ambient test temperatures of 43°C (110°F) and -18°C (0°F), with tolerance ±5°C. |
| Hydrogen Monitoring | Combustible gas monitoring system capable of measuring 400 to 40,000 ppm hydrogen. |
| Calibration Gases | Industrial hydrogen and 2.00% hydrogen in air (nominal). |
| Flame Arrestors | Vented batteries must have flame arrestors tested per UL 1989 to prevent external ignition of internal gases. |
| Single Point Failures | Tests must include induced failures in charging control to simulate worst-case gassing scenarios. |
| Battery Conditioning | Charge to 100% SOC, then discharge to 80% DOD at C/3 rate. |
Engineering design insights from this standard include the importance of testing at both upper and lower battery operating temperature limits, as gassing rates vary significantly with temperature. ⚠️ Additionally, single point failures must be simulated to ensure safety under abnormal conditions, as a single component failure can cause hydrogen generation many times higher than normal. The enclosure must be constructed from materials that limit hydrogen permeation, such as polyvinyl fluoride sheets, and include a safety blow-out panel to relieve pressure from potential explosions. Flame arrestors are mandatory for vented battery systems to prevent flame propagation into the battery.
Why SAE J1718 Was Cancelled
Despite its thorough methodology, SAE J1718 was cancelled in November 2008. The primary reason is the shift in automotive battery technology. Modern electric and hybrid vehicles primarily use sealed battery systems (e.g., lithium-ion, nickel-metal hydride) that do not generate hydrogen during charging. These sealed systems have higher energy density and specific energy, making them more competitive than aqueous batteries, which are now limited to niche applications like neighborhood electric vehicles or special military vehicles. Moreover, hydrogen safety for fuel cell vehicles is addressed by separate standards. As a result, SAE J1718 became irrelevant for the mainstream electric vehicle fleet and was subsequently withdrawn.
Cancellation Notice: SAE J1718 was cancelled in 2008. Engineers working on modern EVs should not reference this standard for hydrogen emission measurement. Instead, consult current safety standards for their specific battery technology.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What is the purpose of measuring hydrogen emissions during charging?
To determine if the hydrogen concentration in a residential garage could reach levels requiring forced ventilation to prevent explosion risks. This is based on NFPA 30 criteria (one-fourth of LFL).
2. Which battery types are covered by this standard?
Only aqueous battery systems (e.g., vented lead-acid) that produce hydrogen during charging. Sealed batteries like lithium-ion do not emit hydrogen and are outside the scope.
3. What are single point failures in the context of this test?
Single point failures refer to a single fault in the charging control circuitry that can cause excessive gassing. The standard requires testing with such failures to simulate worst-case scenarios.
4. Is SAE J1718 still applicable to modern electric vehicles?
No. The standard was cancelled in 2008 and is not relevant for modern EVs with sealed battery systems. It may still be of historical interest or applicable to legacy aqueous battery systems in specialized vehicles.
