Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
Principles and Process for Developing Icons for Electronic Displays (SAE J3113)
As off-road work machines increasingly rely on electronic displays for setup, control, and monitoring, the need for clear and consistent icons becomes critical. SAE J3113 provides a structured approach to developing icons that maintain fidelity with ISO-registered or ISO-compliant graphical symbols. Adhering to this standard ensures that operators can quickly recognize and understand machine functions, improving both usability and safety. 🛠️
Key Principles for Icon Development
The standard outlines several crucial principles that govern the creation and adaptation of icons for electronic displays. These principles ensure that icons are not only visually appealing but also functionally effective.
| Principle | Description | Reference |
|---|---|---|
| Avoid extraneous detail | Keep icons simple and focused on the essential function to enhance recognition and differentiation. | SAE J3113, Sec 5.1 |
| Maintain relative sizing and arrow usage | Adhere to the ISO/IEC 80416 series for arrow forms and relative dimensions within icons. | SAE J3113, Sec 5.2 |
| Ensure minimum contrast ratio | Use adequate contrast between the icon and its background as specified in ISO 9241-303 to preserve legibility. | SAE J3113, Sec 5.3 |
| Preserve visual impression | When adapting a graphical symbol to an icon, maintain its original visual character to ensure recognition. | SAE J3113, Sec 4.1 |
🔍 Engineering Design Insight: Icons should be designed to retain the same silhouette and essential details as the original symbol. Avoid adding unnecessary embellishments that might clutter the icon and reduce comprehension. Testing perceptual quality using ISO 9186-2 can help validate that the icon is easily distinguishable.
The Structured Process for Icon Development
SAE J3113 provides a step-by-step decision process that guides the developer from identifying the need for an icon to final fidelity check. The process ensures that every icon is either derived from a registered symbol or created to be compliant with international standards.
Process Overview
- Determine need – Confirm that an icon is required.
- Search for registered symbol – Check ISO 7000, IEC 60417, or relevant SAE standards for an existing symbol.
- If no registered symbol exists, look for a non-registered symbol – Use existing industry symbols when possible.
- Assess conceptual acceptability – Ensure the symbol correctly represents the function, using expert review or user testing per ISO 9186 series.
- Check ISO compliance – Verify that the symbol drawing follows IEC 80416-1, ISO 80416-2, and IEC 80416-3.
- Apply ISO 80416-4 principles – Adapt the symbol to screen display while preserving the visual impression.
- Verify fidelity – Confirm that the resulting icon retains the essence of the original symbol.
⚠️ Common Mistake: Failing to maintain fidelity with the original registered symbol is a frequent error. Any adaptation must preserve the icon’s visual impression, or the operator may not correctly associate it with the intended function. Always revert to the principles of ISO 80416-4 if fidelity is compromised.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between an icon and a graphical symbol?
According to SAE J3113, a graphical symbol is a visually perceptible figure used to transmit information independent of language. An icon is a digitized (pixelated) representation of a graphical symbol, typically used on electronic displays or graphical user interfaces. The icon should maintain fidelity with the original symbol to ensure consistent recognition.
How can I ensure my icon is ISO-compliant?
To ensure ISO compliance, follow the creation process outlined in IEC 80416-1 for new symbols, and use the adaptation guidelines in ISO 80416-4 for converting existing symbols into icons. Additionally, verify that your icon meets the contrast and sizing requirements of ISO 9241-303 and the ISO 80416 series.
Why is fidelity so important in icon design?
Fidelity ensures that an operator who is familiar with a standard graphical symbol will immediately recognize it when presented as an icon on a display. This reduces cognitive load and the potential for operational errors. SAE J3113 emphasizes that maintaining the visual impression of the original symbol is key to achieving usability in off-road work machines.
What are the consequences of adding extraneous detail to an icon?
Extra details can make an icon harder to identify quickly, especially on small displays or in poor lighting conditions. The principle of simplicity is critical; extraneous decoration distracts from the core function and may reduce the icon’s effectiveness. Always prioritize clarity over cosmetic enhancements.
