Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
Measuring PTU Speed-Dependent Parasitic Loss: The SAE J3039-2020 Standard
As fuel economy and emissions regulations become more stringent, accurately quantifying component-level parasitic losses is critical for vehicle-level modeling. The SAE J3039-2020 recommended practice addresses this need specifically for power transfer units (PTUs) in all-wheel-drive (AWD) passenger cars and SUVs. By providing a common method for measuring speed-dependent parasitic loss, often called spin loss, this standard enables engineers to generate consistent data for driveline efficiency analysis. 🛠️
Why a Standard for PTU Parasitic Loss?
PTUs are geared devices that transmit torque from the transmission to the rear axle in transverse-engine, AWD vehicles. Their internal components—bearings, gears, seals—generate friction and fluid drag that vary with speed and temperature. Prior to J3039, there was no standardized approach to isolate and measure these losses, making it difficult to compare designs or incorporate accurate loss data into vehicle fuel economy simulations. The standard fills this gap by defining test conditions, temperature measurement, and procedures that yield repeatable, representative results.
Key Definitions and Measurement Methodology
Average Skin Temperature (AST)
Rather than relying solely on oil sump temperature, J3039 introduces the Average Skin Temperature (AST), derived from seven k-type thermocouples placed at specific locations on the PTU housing. This metric has been shown to reliably represent the internal core temperature of the unit. The thermocouples are attached using thermally conductive adhesive, with soldered tips for fast response. Non-contact devices are not recommended.
Design Insight: The AST method captures the thermal state of the unit more accurately than a single sump reading, because it averages temperatures at bearing races and housing zones where heat generation and dissipation occur. This is essential for correlating spin loss with stable thermal conditions.
The seven thermocouple locations are:
| Position | Location Description |
|---|---|
| 1 | Input bearing (transmission side) |
| 2 | Input bearing (back side) |
| 3 | Output bearing |
| 4 | Top of input section |
| 5 | Top of output section |
| 6 | Bottom of output section |
| 7 | Bottom of input section |
Sump Temperature and Soak Conditions
In addition to AST, a thermocouple inserted into the drain plug measures the oil sump temperature. This is recorded separately and used together with AST to confirm thermal equilibrium. The standard requires a temperature-controlled chamber capable of reaching an AST range of –7 °C to +65 °C. Soak times are specified: an initial 4-hour pre-soak, followed by a 45-minute hold at the target temperature. Between test runs, the AST must return to within 5 °C of the target before another 45-minute soak to ensure consistency. 🔍
Test Procedure and Repeatability
The spin loss test is performed by sweeping input speed while measuring input torque at each step. Stabilization time is needed to eliminate inertial effects from the dynamometer; the torque measurement is recorded when instantaneous values fall within ±2% of the mean. Run-to-run repeatability is defined by a coefficient of variation (CV) less than 6.0% under the same conditions. This ensures that the data can be reliably used for modeling fuel economy and emissions.
⚠️ Safety Note on Cooling: If liquid nitrogen (LN2) is used to achieve low temperatures, avoid any direct splashing onto the unit under test. LN2 may damage the PTU seals and housing. Use an indirect convection loop as described in the standard.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the purpose of using seven thermocouples for AST?
Multiple thermocouples average out local variations and provide a global measure of the PTU’s thermal state. This is more representative of internal conditions than a single point, especially when temperature gradients exist across the housing.
How is sump temperature different from AST?
Sump temperature is the oil temperature in the drain plug region, while AST is a composite of skin temperatures at bearing and housing locations. Both are recorded, but only AST is used for the defined soak target.
What is the required soak time for stable measurements?
The standard mandates a 4-hour pre-soak followed by a 45-minute soak at target AST. Between runs, the AST must recover to within 5 °C of the target, then soak again for 45 minutes before the next measurement.
Why is the coefficient of variation limited to 6%?
This criterion ensures that the torque measurements are repeatable across runs, building confidence that the data reflect the true loss characteristics of the PTU rather than test variability.
