Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
IEC TR 61912-2:2009 โ Low-Voltage Switchgear and Controlgear โ Application Guide
Engineering guide to over-current protective device coordination for electrical distribution systems
📌 Scope: IEC TR 61912-2:2009 provides technical guidance on selectivity (discrimination) between over-current protective devices (OCPDs) in low-voltage electrical installations. It covers selectivity between circuit-breakers, fuses, motor protection relays, RCDs, and combinations thereof, including zone selective interlocking (ZSI) techniques.
1. Selectivity Fundamentals and Device Combinations
Selectivity — also called discrimination — is the ability of a protective device coordination scheme to isolate a faulted circuit by opening only the device immediately upstream of the fault, while leaving upstream devices closed to maintain power to healthy sections. IEC TR 61912-2 classifies selectivity into two main categories: overload selectivity (for currents up to the rated short-circuit capacity of the downstream device) and short-circuit selectivity (for fault currents exceeding the overload range).
The standard systematically analyzes selectivity between every practical combination of OCPD types, including circuit-breaker/circuit-breaker, circuit-breaker/fuse, fuse/fuse, circuit-breaker/motor-overload-relay, and fuse/CPS (control protective device) combinations. For each combination, the standard specifies the verification method using time-current characteristic curves and let-through energy (I²t) comparisons.
| Upstream Device (UD) | Downstream Device (DD) | Selectivity Method | Typical I²t Threshold |
|---|---|---|---|
| Circuit-breaker (MCCB) | Circuit-breaker (MCB) | Time-current curve comparison | UD I²t_min > DD I²t_max |
| Circuit-breaker | Fuse (gG/gL) | Overload: curve; SC: I²t | Fuse I²t at UD rating × 1.3 safety factor |
| Fuse (gG) | Circuit-breaker | Time-current + I²t window | 5× to 10× DD rated current |
| Fuse (gG) | Fuse (gG) | Rated current ratio (≥1.6:1) | N/A (ratio-based) |
| Circuit-breaker | Motor overload relay | Through-fault coordination | OL relay must not trip during CB clearing |
⚠️ Engineering Consideration: The 1.6:1 ratio rule for fuse-to-fuse selectivity is a well-known thumb rule but requires careful verification under real fault conditions. The standard notes that this ratio ensures selectivity only when both fuses operate within their characteristic curves at the same temperature. Ambient temperature derating (typically 0.1% per °C above 30 °C) and preloading effects can reduce the effective ratio and should be factored into the design.
2. Residual Current Device (RCD) Selectivity
A significant portion of IEC TR 61912-2 addresses selectivity between RCDs (RCCBs and RCBOs). Two distinct fault types require separate analysis: earth-leakage currents (slowly rising, typically below 1 A) and earth-fault currents (fast-rising, potentially exceeding hundreds of amperes). For earth-leakage selectivity, the standard recommends using time-delayed Type S (selective) RCDs upstream with instantaneous RCDs downstream, with minimum grading intervals of 0.1 s for Type S devices.
For earth-fault current selectivity, the operating characteristics of the over-current protection element (the MCB part of an RCBO) dominate. The standard provides detailed guidance on coordinating RCBOs in series, noting that full selectivity up to the rated short-circuit capacity is achievable only when the downstream RCBO has sufficient impedance to limit the fault current below the instantaneous trip threshold of the upstream RCBO.
| Fault Type | Upstream Device | Downstream Device | Selectivity Achievable |
|---|---|---|---|
| Earth-leakage (AC) | RCD Type S, 300 mA, 0.3 s delay | RCD Type AC, 30 mA, instantaneous | Full up to 300 mA leakage |
| Earth-leakage (pulsating DC) | RCD Type S, 300 mA | RCD Type A, 30 mA | Full (with waveform consideration) |
| Earth-fault (short-circuit) | RCBO with time-delay | RCBO instantaneous | Partial (depends on fault level) |
✅ Engineering Insight: One of the most practical contributions of the standard is its guidance on cascade (series) ratings. In a well-designed distribution board, the main switch (upstream) may have a 50 kA rated short-circuit capacity while downstream MCBs are rated at only 10 kA — the upstream device’s current-limiting action protects the downstream devices. The standard provides the I²t let-through energy criteria to validate cascade protection: the upstream device must limit the peak let-through current and energy to within the downstream device’s capability.
3. Zone Selective Interlocking (ZSI)
IEC TR 61912-2 introduces Zone Selective Interlocking (ZSI) as an advanced technique for improving selectivity without sacrificing fault clearing speed. In a conventional time-graded system, the upstream breaker must wait for a coordination delay (typically 0.1 to 0.5 s per zone) before tripping, which increases arc flash energy and equipment stress. ZSI eliminates this delay by using communication between protection devices.
The operating principle is straightforward: when a downstream protective device detects a fault, it sends a “restraint” signal upstream. If an upstream device receives this restraint signal, it delays its trip to allow the downstream device to clear the fault. If no restraint signal is received, the upstream device trips instantaneously — meaning it is seeing a fault in its own zone. This provides both selectivity (for downstream faults) and instantaneous clearing (for direct faults). The standard provides example schematics for ZSI implementation in multi-source distribution systems.
ZSI Logic Example (from IEC TR 61912-2):
IF (fault_current > Ii_set) AND (restraint_input = FALSE)
THEN trip INSTANTANEOUSLY
ELSE IF (fault_current > Ii_set) AND (restraint_input = TRUE)
THEN trip AFTER coordination_delay
ELSE (fault_current > Ir_set but < Ii_set)
trip per inverse-time characteristic
END IF
🔥 Critical Design Challenge: ZSI requires reliable communication between protective devices. The standard highlights that the restraint signal path must be fail-safe — a loss of communication must default to the more conservative time-graded operation rather than loss of selectivity. Designers should use dedicated signaling wiring (not shared with general-purpose communications) and implement continuous line monitoring. Typical ZSI wiring uses 24 VDC pilot wires with a “current loop” topology where the absence of current (0 mA) signals “no restraint” (instantaneous trip allowed) and a nominal 20 mA signals “restraint active.”
4. Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: What is the difference between total selectivity and partial selectivity?
A: Total selectivity means that the downstream device clears all over-currents up to its rated short-circuit capacity without the upstream device operating. Partial selectivity means selectivity is assured only up to a specified current level lower than the downstream device’s breaking capacity. Above that level, both devices may trip. The standard specifies test procedures and acceptance criteria for both types.
Q2: How does standing load affect selectivity in the overload zone?
A: Standing load (the background current flowing through the upstream device) shifts the upstream device’s thermal state closer to its trip threshold, effectively reducing the overload selectivity margin. IEC TR 61912-2 advises applying a derating factor to the upstream device’s overload trip curve when standing loads exceed 70% of its rated current. The standard provides worked examples in Annex B showing how standing load can reduce the available selectivity current range by 20-35%.
Q3: Can selectivity be achieved between a circuit-breaker and a contactor?
A: Yes, but with specific constraints. The standard covers circuit-breaker coordination with contactors and motor starters in Type 1 and Type 2 coordination classifications. Type 2 coordination requires that after a fault, the contactor contacts may be welded but must be easily separable (no damage to other components). The circuit-breaker’s let-through energy must be limited to protect the contactor’s withstand rating, typically using current-limiting breakers with low I²t values.
Q4: What documentation is required for demonstrating selectivity compliance?
A: The standard recommends that manufacturers publish selectivity tables for their device combinations, verified by type testing. For custom installations, a selectivity study report must include: single-line diagrams with device ratings, time-current curves plotted on log-log scales showing all device characteristics, calculated fault currents at each bus location, I²t let-through energy calculations for the worst-case fault scenario, and a selectivity assessment table identifying which fault scenarios achieve full, partial, or no selectivity.
