Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
Drawbar Test Procedure for Construction and Forestry Machines: SAE J872-2003 Essentials
SAE J872-2003 specifies a standardized method for measuring the drawbar pull performance of self-propelled construction, forestry, and industrial machines. Although cancelled and superseded by SAE J/ISO 7464, the principles in this standard remain foundational for tractive performance testing. This article distills the key requirements, best practices, and common pitfalls to help engineers ensure accurate and repeatable drawbar pull measurements.
1. Understanding the Drawbar Test Standard
The standard defines procedures for measuring drawbar pull, drawbar power, and wheel or track slip against travel speed. It applies to off-road work machines as listed in SAE J1116, including tractors, loaders, graders, and crawlers. The test is designed to characterize the machine’s ability to generate tractive force under controlled conditions.
Test Site Requirements:
- Straight, level track with a minimum length of 100 m (330 ft) plus approaches for stabilization.
- Grade must be less than 0.5%; if exceeded, runs must be taken in both directions and averaged.
- Surface: For rubber-tired machines, prefer coarse concrete or asphalt; for crawlers and steel-wheeled machines, use well-packed earth.
- Turning areas at both ends must allow easy maneuvering of the test train.
Key Definitions:
- Drawbar Pull: horizontal towing force at the hitch point (kN or lbf).
- Drawbar Power: product of travel speed and drawbar pull (kW or hp).
- Wheel/Track Slip: percentage difference in drive wheel revolutions between loaded and unloaded conditions over the same distance.
- Machine Mass: includes operator, full fuel tank, and all fluids at specified levels.
🔍 Design Insight: Maintaining a horizontal line of pull is critical. The hitch height must be adjusted on the dynamometer car to keep the pull horizontal. For ground-engaging machines (e.g., graders, scrapers), attach the load no more than 100 mm (4 in) above ground level. An angled pull distorts force readings and affects slip calculations.
2. Instrumentation and Preparation for Accurate Testing
The dynamometer car must be capable of controlling either engine speed or drawbar pull within tight limits. The table below summarizes the required instrumentation accuracies as specified in the standard:
| Parameter | Accuracy |
|---|---|
| Time | ±0.2 s |
| Distance | ±0.5% |
| Drawbar Pull | ±1.0% |
| Engine Speed (r/min) | ±1.0% |
| Drive Wheel/Sprocket Revolutions | ±0.5% |
| Machine Mass | ±1.5% of measured mass |
| Tire Pressure | ±3.0% |
| Temperature (wet/dry bulb) | ±1 °C (±1.8 °F) |
| Barometric Pressure | ±0.35 kPa (±1.2 in Hg) |
Machine Preparation Steps:
- Engine and PTO adjustments per manufacturer’s specifications.
- Add payload, ballast, or attachments as required; then weigh machine to obtain total mass and distribution.
- For rubber-tired machines, drive under partial load (1/2 to 3/4 of maximum) in low gear to create a wear pattern. If full tread width contact is not achieved, lower tire pressure cautiously.
- Adjust track tension on crawlers to manufacturer’s specification.
- Determine free roll revolutions by driving the machine in lowest gear at low speed with no steering corrections over at least 50 m (165 ft). This unloaded revolution count is essential for slip calculation.
⚠️ Critical Caution: Do not reduce tire pressure below the low limit for the actual weight carried on each tire. Always follow the machine manufacturer’s recommendations. Also, tire tread or grouser wear must not exceed 50% of the original depth to maintain consistent traction.
3. Test Procedure and Common Mistakes
Procedure Overview:
- Operate the machine until engine, transmission, and final drive fluids reach operating temperature.
- Set engine controls to maximum power position for all test runs.
- For each gear or ratio, adjust the dynamometer load to maintain the specified speed (engine, drive wheels, or output shaft). Record drawbar pull, time, distance, engine r/min, and drive revolutions.
- Alternatively, control drawbar pull constant and record the same data.
- Make runs in both directions to compensate for grade, averaging results.
- Ensure steering is minimal; wheel revolutions on each side must not vary more than 3% (2% for sprockets).
- Check that instantaneous speed does not vary more than ±3% from the specified speed during a run.
Common Mistakes to Avoid:
- Testing on a grade >0.5% without averaging bidirectional runs.
- Using an incorrect hitch height that results in a non-horizontal line of pull.
- Failing to stabilize load before entering the test section.
- Calculating slip using loaded revolutions only – free roll revolutions from a separate unloaded run are mandatory.
- Allowing tire wear or grouser depth degradation beyond 50%.
- Not reporting ambient conditions (temperature, humidity, barometric pressure) as required.
- Using a test distance shorter than the recommended 100 m.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I set up the drawbar pull test to ensure accurate tractive performance measurement?
Begin by selecting a straight, level test track with less than 0.5% grade. Use a dynamometer car capable of controlling either speed or pull within the required limits. Ensure the hitch point maintains a horizontal line of pull, and that the machine is prepared with correct ballast, tire pressure, and track tension. Run preliminary passes to stabilize loads and drive conditions before recording data.
What is the correct hitch height for drawbar testing?
For general machines, set the height per the manufacturer’s recommendation. For towing hitch or drawbar, use the normal towing attachment point. For ground-engaging machines (graders, scrapers), the load attachment must be no more than 100 mm above ground level. In all cases, the line of pull must be horizontal to avoid force measurement errors.
How is wheel slip calculated in this procedure?
Slip is the percentage difference between the number of drive wheel revolutions under load and the number of revolutions over the same distance when unloaded (free roll). Conduct a separate free roll run in the lowest gear at low speed with no steering corrections over at least 50 m. Use the formula: Slip (%) = [(Loaded Revolutions – Free Roll Revolutions) / Loaded Revolutions] × 100.
What surfaces are acceptable for rubber-tired vs. crawler machines?
For rubber-tired machines, preferred surfaces are coarse concrete or bituminous (asphalt). For crawlers and steel-wheeled machines, use compacted earth courses that are well packed and cohesive. Other surfaces may be used for special purposes, but the nature of the surface must be reported in the test results.
By following SAE J872-2003 principles and avoiding common missteps, engineers can obtain reliable tractive performance data that supports machine development, validation, and customer expectations.
