Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
D5640-95 – Standard Test Method Technical Guide
🧠 Foundational Concepts for Primary Devices
ASTM D5640-95 (Reapproved 2014) provides a framework for selecting weirs and flumes based on hydraulic principles. The universal requirement for accurate measurement is the establishment of critical flow (Froude number = 1.0) within the control section. Key parameters defined in the standard include:
- Critical Flow: The condition where specific energy is minimized for a given discharge.
- Froude Number: A dimensionless ratio of inertial to gravity forces (Fr = V / √(gD)).
- Head (H): The water depth measured relative to the weir or flume crest.
- Backwater: The rise in upstream water surface elevation caused by the hydraulic obstruction.
📏 Primary Devices and Applicable ASTM Standards
The standard guides users to devices covered by dedicated test methods. Selection depends on flow conditions, accuracy requirements, and fluid characteristics.
| 🟦 Device Type | 📏 Standard Designation | 📐 Typical Application |
|---|---|---|
| Thin-Plate Weirs | D5242 | High accuracy measurement of clean water |
| Broad-Crested Weirs | D5614 | Slurries and flows requiring robust construction |
| Parshall Flumes | D1941 | Wastewater, irrigation, and flows with suspended solids |
| Palmer-Bowlus Flumes | D5390 | Flow measurement in partially filled circular conduits |
⚖️ Comparative Selection Criteria
Choosing the appropriate primary device requires balancing several trade-offs. The table below summarizes key differences based on the recommendations in D5640.
| 🟦 Criterion | 📏 Flumes (Parshall / Palmer-Bowlus) | 📐 Weirs (Thin-Plate / Broad-Crested) |
|---|---|---|
| Head Loss | Low (suitable for flat gradients) | High (requires significant drop) |
| Solids Handling | Excellent (self-cleaning velocities) | Poor (debris can accumulate, affecting accuracy) |
| Upstream Reach | Short approach section sufficient | Long, straight approach required |
| Accuracy Potential | Good to Excellent | Very High (under ideal conditions) |
🎯 Critical Flow Requirement
All primary devices depend on the establishment of critical flow (Froude number = 1.0) within the control section. Failure to achieve this condition invalidates the standard rating tables and requires a velocity-area method (D3858) or acoustic method (D5389).
💡 Streamlining Selection
For applications involving high levels of grease, floatables, or sediment, Parshall flumes are generally preferred over thin-plate weirs to prevent clogging and minimize maintenance.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
🔍 What is the primary principle behind weirs and flumes?
They function by accelerating flow through a constriction to achieve critical flow (Fr = 1.0), creating a unique relationship between upstream head (H) and volumetric discharge (Q).
💡 Which ASTM standard governs the thin-plate weir?
Test Method D5242 covers the measurement of open-channel flow using thin-plate weirs, detailing standard contracted and suppressed configurations.
⚡ What is the Froude number?
Defined as the ratio of inertial forces to gravitational forces (V / √(gD)). A Froude number of 1.0 indicates critical flow, which is the necessary condition for a unique stage-discharge rating.
📌 When should a Palmer-Bowlus flume be selected over a Parshall flume?
Palmer-Bowlus flumes (D5390) are specifically designed for installation in manholes and existing circular sewer pipes, whereas Parshall flumes