Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
D5362-13 – Standard Test Method Technical Guide
🎯 Scope and Application
The D5362 – 13 (Reapproved 2018) test method is the standard procedure for determining the snagging resistance of fabrics using a Bean Bag apparatus. This method is specifically designed and validated for woven and knitted fabrics constructed from textured or untextured filament yarns, spun yarns, or combinations thereof.
Users must be aware of explicit limitations. The method is not suitable for (1) open construction fabrics like nets because the chamber pins will snag the bean bag instead of the specimen, (2) heavy or stiff fabrics that cannot be formed into a cover, and (3) tufted or nonwoven fabrics, as the apparatus is calibrated for woven/knitted structures. In accordance with Section 1.3, metric units shall prevail in the case of any referee decisions.
⚠️ Critical Exclusion: Open construction fabrics (e.g., nets, fishnet knits) must not be tested using this method. The test pins will interact with the underlying bean bag and chamber, producing invalid, non-representative snagging data. For such materials, consult alternative methods like AATCC 65 which is acknowledged in the standard for these specific constructions.
⚙️ Test Procedure and Referenced Standards
The test method requires constructing a fabric cover for a standard bean bag from the test specimen. This assembly is placed into a rotating cylindrical chamber lined with sharp pins. Controlled tumbling action causes the pins to randomly contact the fabric surface, simulating the snagging mechanisms encountered in service. Snagging is then evaluated against standard ratings or photographic standards.
The standard mandates conditioning and testing in accordance with Practice D1776. The method is closely related to the Mace Test (D3939) for snagging resistance, though it employs a distinct mechanical mechanism. Specific precautionary statements for safe operation are outlined in Section 7 of the standard.
| 🟦 Designation | 📐 Title | 🎯 Relevance to Test Method |
|---|---|---|
| D123 | Terminology Relating to Textiles | General textile definitions |
| D1776 | Practice for Conditioning and Testing Textiles | Standardized humidity & temperature control |
| D3939 | Test Method for Snagging Resistance of Fabrics (Mace) | Alternative snagging test procedure |
| D4850 | Terminology Relating to Fabrics and Fabric Test Methods | Specific fabric snagging definitions |
| AATCC 65 | Snag Resistance of Women’s Nylon Hosiery | Acknowledged alternative for open construction |
📊 Fabric Suitability and Key Terminology
Accurate testing relies on correctly classifying the fabric specimen. The standard explicitly defines the boundaries of its applicability. Terminology is critical; key terms such as snag, protrusion, distortion, and color contrast in textiles are formally defined in Terminology D4850. General textile terms are defined in Terminology D123.
| 🟦 Fabric Type / Construction | 📏 Suitability | ⚡ Rationale |
|---|---|---|
| Woven / Knitted (Filament & Spun Yarns) | ✅ Suitable | Within the validated scope of the method. |
| Open Construction (Nets, Mesh) | ❌ Not Suitable | Pins snag the bean bag, not the specimen. |
| Heavy or Stiff Fabrics | ❌ Not Suitable | Cannot be conformed into a proper bean bag cover. |
| Tufted / Nonwoven Fabrics | ❌ Not Suitable | Apparatus mechanism is designed for woven/knit structures only. |
💡 Best Practice: When conducting interlaboratory testing or referee decisions, remember that metric units take precedence. Ensure all data sheets and reports reflect SI units as the primary measurement system to maintain full compliance with the standard and Practice D4467 for non-normally distributed data, if applicable.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
🔍 What is the basic principle of the Bean Bag snagging test?
The fabric specimen is fabricated into a cover for a weighted bean bag. This assembly is tumbled inside a rotating cylindrical chamber lined with sharp, protruding pins. The dynamic tumbling action causes the pins to repeatedly contact and pull at the fabric surface, producing snags that are then visually rated against standard photographic references.
💡 Which fabric constructions are explicitly excluded from D5362?
The standard explicitly excludes (1) open construction fabrics (e.g., nets) where the pins snag the bag instead of the fabric, (2) heavy or stiff fabrics that cannot be made into a cover, and (3) tufted or nonwoven fabrics. The apparatus is specifically designed and validated only for woven and knitted fabrics from textured or untextured filament or spun yarns.
⚡ How does D5362 (Bean Bag) differ from D3939 (Mace)?
Both standards test snagging resistance using a tumbling mechanism with pins. D3939 (Mace) uses a mace-like object covered in pins that tumbles freely with the fabric. D5362 (Bean Bag) uses a bean bag covered by the fabric specimen that is tumbled against stationary pins mounted on the chamber walls. They provide complementary data on snagging behavior.
📌 Why is conditioning testing per D1776 critical for this standard?
Textile materials are hygroscopic and exhibit different mechanical properties (e.g., stiffness, tenacity, yarn friction) based on moisture content and temperature. Standardized conditioning as specified in D1776 ensures that all test specimens are evaluated under equilibrium atmospheric conditions, minimizing variability and ensuring reproducible results across different laboratories and testing dates.