๐ฌ BS EN ISO 9015 is a British Standard published by BSI implementing the European Standard EN ISO 9015. It is a destructive test on welds standard specifying hardness testing of welds in metallic materials. Hardness is an important indicator of the overall quality of a welded joint: the hardness distribution across the weld metal, heat-affected zone (HAZ) and parent metal reflects both strength and toughness and can reveal potential cold-cracking and hardened-microstructure problems. The series has two parts: Part 1 specifies the hardness test on arc welded joints, and Part 2 specifies microhardness testing of welded joints.
๐ก The hardness distribution of a welded joint is the “microscopic profile” of weld quality: excessive hardness suggests hardened microstructure and cold-cracking risk, while too-low hardness suggests softening or inadequate strength. Systematic hardness measurement across the weld, HAZ and parent metal gives a full assessment of joint performance.
1. Series Structure and Scope ๐
The BS EN ISO 9015 series falls under ICS 25.160.40 (welded joints); UK participation was entrusted to BSI Technical Committee WEE/2, “Destructive Testing of Welds”. The series has two parts:
| Part | Standard No. | Content | Typical Application |
| Part 1 | BS EN ISO 9015-1:2011 | Hardness test on arc welded joints | Macro hardness distribution (conventional hardness tester) |
| Part 2 | BS EN ISO 9015-2:2016 | Microhardness testing of welded joints | Micro-region hardness distribution (microhardness tester) |
Part 1 is identical to ISO 9015-1:2001 and supersedes BS EN 1043-1:1996; Part 2 supersedes the 2011 edition and adopts the latest content of ISO 9015-2:2016.
2. Hardness Test on Arc Welded Joints (Part 1) ๐
Part 1 specifies hardness testing of arc welded joints using conventional hardness methods (e.g. Vickers HV, Brinell HB or Rockwell HRC). Main content includes:
- Test principle: press an indenter into the specimen surface under a defined load and determine the hardness from indentation size or depth;
- Specimen preparation: cut a specimen from the welded joint and grind/polish it flat to meet hardness-test surface requirements;
- Test location: arrange measurement lines perpendicular to the weld centreline to measure hardness of weld metal, HAZ sub-zones and parent metal;
- Expression of results: represent hardness as a distribution plot or table versus position to assess uniformity and any abnormally hard zones.
โ ๏ธ Test location directly determines the representativeness of the hardness distribution. Measurement lines should cover the weld metal, the HAZ near the fusion line (fine-grain, coarse-grain, critical zones) and the parent metal, with small enough spacing to capture the hardness peak in the HAZ โ hardened microstructure concentrates near the fusion line.
3. Microhardness Testing of Welded Joints (Part 2) ๐ง
Part 2 specifies microhardness testing (usually Vickers microhardness at small loads such as HV0.2 to HV1) to determine the micro-region hardness distribution of a welded joint. Compared with macro hardness, microhardness offers:
- Micro-region resolution: the small-load indentation is tiny, allowing measurement of hardness differences between HAZ sub-zones (coarse-grain, fine-grain, critical zones);
- Precise positioning: point-by-point measurement of the hardness gradient at the weld/HAZ/parent-metal interface, revealing microstructural non-uniformity;
- Thin walls and micro-joints: suitable for hardness testing of thin plate and small weld specimens.
Microhardness testing requires higher specimen surface quality: specimens must be carefully cut, mounted, ground and polished to a flat, work-hardening-layer-free surface, otherwise indentation measurement accuracy is affected.
๐ก Microhardness and macro hardness are complementary: macro hardness evaluates the overall joint hardness level, while microhardness finely characterises the HAZ hardness gradient. Together they give a full diagnosis of joint microstructure and properties.
4. Test Methods and Quality Control ๐
Whichever part is used, the following quality control measures should be applied:
- Instrument calibration: calibrate the hardness tester periodically with standard hardness blocks to ensure accurate load and indentation measurement;
- Surface preparation: the specimen surface should be flat, smooth, free from scale and contamination; microhardness specimens should avoid over-polishing that creates a work-hardening layer;
- Point recording: record the position coordinates and hardness value of each point accurately for plotting the distribution curve;
- Duplicate measurement: repeat measurements on multiple lines in the same section where necessary to verify consistency;
- Reporting: report should include specimen identification, welding procedure, test-location diagram, hardness values and the test method used.
5. Engineering Practice Applications ๐ ๏ธ
- ๐ Welding procedure qualification: hardness testing is a mandatory item in welding procedure qualification (WPQR) to verify that process parameters do not make the joint too hard or too soft.
- ๐ Cold-cracking risk assessment: an excessive HAZ hardness peak suggests hardened microstructure and increased cold-cracking sensitivity, requiring adjustment of preheat, heat input and post-weld treatment.
- ๐ง On-site weld inspection: for pressure-containing welds such as vessels and pipes, hardness testing is often a destructive sampling item, combined with non-destructive testing.
- ๐ Failure analysis: hardness distribution analysis of failed welded structures can reconstruct the microstructural state of the failure region and help determine the cause.
6. Frequently Asked Questions โ
โ Q: How should Parts 1 and 2 of BS EN ISO 9015 be chosen?
A: Part 1 uses a conventional hardness tester for macro hardness distribution of arc welded joints, suitable for routine qualification; Part 2 uses a microhardness tester for micro-region hardness gradients, suitable for fine analysis of HAZ sub-zones and thin-wall joints. Use both where necessary.
โ Q: Why does the HAZ hardness peak deserve special attention?
A: The coarse-grain zone near the fusion line easily forms hardened martensite/bainite, causing excessive hardness and increased cold-cracking sensitivity. The hardness peak is a key signal of joint embrittlement.
โ Q: What special requirements does microhardness testing place on the specimen?
A: The specimen must be cut, mounted, ground and polished to a mirror finish without residual work-hardening layer or contamination, otherwise indentation measurement is distorted and hardness values are inaccurate.
๐ Q: Can hardness testing replace non-destructive testing?
A: No, but they complement each other. NDT detects macroscopic defects (cracks, porosity, lack of fusion); hardness testing reflects microstructural and property state. Together they give a full weld-quality assessment.