Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
ASME N45.2.23-1978 — Qualification of Quality Assurance Program Audit Personnel for Nuclear Power Plants
📐 ANSI/ASME N45.2.23-1978 provides requirements and guidance for the qualification of quality assurance program audit personnel (auditors and lead auditors) for nuclear power plants. Developed by Work Group N45-2.23 on Qualification of Auditors under ANSI Committee N45 (initial draft prepared January 25, 1974) and approved by ANSI on April 20, 1978, it is the personnel companion to N45.2.12 (Auditing of QA Programs) and answers the question “who audits?” — combining education, training, experience, and examination to ensure that audit conclusions are reliable and credible.
💡 Audit quality depends on auditor quality. N45.2.23 builds auditor qualification on four pillars — education and experience, specialized training, examination, and continued maintenance — a model that anticipates today’s internationally accepted auditor qualification schemes.
1. Scope and Qualification Framework 📌
The Standard provides qualification requirements and guidance for QA program audit personnel. Per its table of contents, it covers qualifications of auditors and lead auditors, maintenance of qualification, administration, and records. Auditor qualification is determined from education, training, and experience and confirmed in writing by the organization; lead auditors must, in addition, have the experience and ability to lead an audit team.
⚠️ Qualification is not “one-time and permanent”: the Standard requires maintenance of proficiency through continued audit participation and training, and requalification when necessary, to prevent audit competence from degrading over time.
2. Qualification of Auditors and Lead Auditors 🔧
| Element | Auditor | Lead Auditor |
|---|---|---|
| Education | Technical education appropriate to the audit area | Higher than the auditor requirement |
| Experience | Relevant experience in the audited area | Experience leading and organizing audit teams |
| Training | QA and audit technique/method training completed | Dedicated lead-auditor training and internship |
| Examination | Pass an organizationally recognized qualification examination | Pass the corresponding examination and obtain written certification |
| Independence & skills | Inquiry, verification, documentation, and reporting skills | Planning, coordination, synthesis, and decision skills |
🚨 Independence is the auditor’s “professional bottom line”: an auditor must not audit activities for which he or she has direct responsibility or a personal interest, or the audit conclusions lose objectivity. Organizations should specifically check for conflicts when assigning audit tasks.
3. Maintenance of Qualification, Requalification, and Administration 🔩
Section 3 requires maintaining qualification through periodic audit participation, training courses, and tracking standard updates; Section 4 sets organizational responsibility for qualification examination; Section 5 requires retaining qualification records and issuing certification documents to qualified personnel. Appendix A provides a reference format for the lead auditor qualification record for organizations establishing qualification files.
✅ Good practice: build an “auditor qualification matrix” that manages personnel by area (design, manufacturing, installation, testing, etc.) and level (auditor/lead auditor), so task assignment can verify qualification, experience, and independence at a glance — the right person for the right job.
4. Engineering Practice Essentials 🛠️
- 🔍 Establish qualification files: maintain a qualification record per Appendix A format for each auditor, including evidence of education, experience, training, and examination.
- 🔧 Systematic training: include the N45.2 series, audit techniques, nonconformance handling, and communication skills in auditor training curricula.
- 📊 Periodic review: evaluate each auditor’s workload and proficiency against the annual audit plan; arrange refresher training or requalification as needed.
- 📋 Auditable records: qualification records, certification documents, and re-review records are retained for internal management, customer audits, and regulatory inspection.
Two problems recur in the practical management of auditor qualification. The first is “certified but not competent”: a person passes the examination yet lacks depth in the discipline being audited — welding, nondestructive examination, instrumentation and control — and can only verify that documents exist rather than judge whether the technical content is sound. The remedy is to subdivide qualification by technical area, to require that auditors in a given field possess the corresponding engineering background and experience, and to bring in technical specialists where the audit scope demands expert judgment. The second is independence that exists only on paper: the auditor has no formal responsibility for the audited activity but has long-standing business dependence or personal ties to the audited department. Organizations should verify independence when assigning audit tasks, retain the record of that check, and, where necessary, have the senior quality function make the assignment directly.
Qualification records should be maintained as living documents rather than archived certificates. Each record should show the auditor’s education, technical experience, audit training, examinations passed, audits performed as team member and as lead, and the date of the most recent proficiency review. This allows the quality manager to answer three questions quickly for any planned audit: is this person qualified for this technical area, has this person audited recently enough to remain proficient, and is this person independent of the activity. Appendix A of the Standard provides a model lead-auditor qualification record that organizations can adopt with little modification, and the discipline of keeping such records up to date is itself one of the clearest indicators of a functioning quality assurance program — an auditor qualification file that is current, complete, and auditable says as much about the organization as the qualifications it documents.
5. Frequently Asked Questions ❓
❓ Q: Can auditor and lead auditor qualifications be obtained at the same time?
A: Yes, but they are typically developed progressively: first obtain auditor qualification and accumulate audit experience, then obtain lead auditor qualification through dedicated training, internship, and examination.
A: Yes, but they are typically developed progressively: first obtain auditor qualification and accumulate audit experience, then obtain lead auditor qualification through dedicated training, internship, and examination.
❓ Q: Who organizes the qualification examination?
A: The organization (e.g., the QA department or an authorized body) organizes it; formats may include written exams, interviews, and assessment of actual audit performance. The Standard requires the examination to be held and results documented.
A: The organization (e.g., the QA department or an authorized body) organizes it; formats may include written exams, interviews, and assessment of actual audit performance. The Standard requires the examination to be held and results documented.
❓ Q: Is qualification lost after long absence from auditing?
A: Yes. The Standard requires maintenance of proficiency; personnel who have been inactive in audits or training for a long time should restore or confirm qualification through the requalification process.
A: Yes. The Standard requires maintenance of proficiency; personnel who have been inactive in audits or training for a long time should restore or confirm qualification through the requalification process.
🔍 Q: Does this Standard apply to suppliers’ audit personnel?
A: Yes. In the nuclear QA system, personnel performing QA audits at suppliers must also meet the applicable qualification requirements; owners may require suppliers to provide auditor qualification evidence and verify it during surveillance or audits.
A: Yes. In the nuclear QA system, personnel performing QA audits at suppliers must also meet the applicable qualification requirements; owners may require suppliers to provide auditor qualification evidence and verify it during surveillance or audits.
