Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
ASME MC88.2-1974 — Procedure for Bench Calibration of Tank Level Gaging Tapes and Sounding Rules
📏 ASME MC88.2-1974, originally designated ANSI B88.2-1974, is a concise, practical calibration standard prepared by the Subcommittee on Liquid Level of American National Standards Committee B88 “Calibration of Instruments.” Its subject is the bench calibration of tank level gaging tapes and sounding rules — the graduated measuring devices used to determine the level of liquid in tanks. The Standard applies to any gaging tape or sounding rule that uses a graduated scale to determine liquid level, and it provides procedures for both linear and non-linear (expanded) scales. It specifies the reference equipment required, the test bench setup, tension and temperature control, the detailed test steps, and the manner of presenting results, making it a key reference for periodic verification of tank gauging devices in oil storage, chemical tank farms, and metrology laboratories.
💡 Calibration of a gaging tape is essentially a “scale comparison”: the tape under test is compared point by point with a traceable reference line scale under controlled tension and temperature, revealing the error distribution along the entire length.
1. Introduction and Scope 📌
The procedure was drafted by the Subcommittee on Liquid Level of ANSI Standards Committee B88, approved by the Subcommittee and the Standards Committee, and granted final approval as an American National Standard on January 9, 1974. The document is compact — roughly ten pages — and organized as: Introduction, Equipment Required, Test Setup, Test Procedure, Presentation of Results, and Bibliography. Its scope covers any gaging tape or sounding rule with a graduated scale reading tank liquid level, including linear scales that read level height directly and non-linear or expanded scales that read volume, weight, or other quantities directly.
⚠️ This Standard addresses bench calibration — a static comparison of the tape against a reference on a calibration bench. It does not replace on-tank installation checks, nor does it cover system-level calibration of complete level instruments such as servo or radar level gauges.
2. Calibration Reference Equipment 🔬
The quality of the reference determines the credibility of the calibration. The Standard requires that the reference be a line scale or tape with metric or English graduations; that its accuracy be at least three times, and preferably ten times, the accuracy required of the device under test; that the reference be traceable to the National Bureau of Standards (NBS, today NIST); and that its overall length suit the length of the device being calibrated. If the reference accuracy is less than ten times the required accuracy, the calibration of the reference itself must be taken into account. A means of applying tension up to 20 pounds (90 Newtons) is also required.
| Reference Requirement | Standard Requirement | Remarks |
|---|---|---|
| Graduations | Metric or English | Read against the tape scale being calibrated |
| Accuracy | At least 3×, preferably 10× the required accuracy | If below 10×, the reference uncertainty must be included |
| Traceability | Traceable to the national standards laboratory (NBS/NIST) | Keeps values consistent with the international measurement system |
| Length | Appropriate to the length of the device under test | Permits comparison over the full length |
| Tension means | Up to 20 lb (90 N) | Meets the tension requirements of long tapes |
3. Test Setup and Tension/Temperature Control 🌡️
The Standard sets explicit test-bench requirements: the tape or rule shall be supported throughout its total length on a horizontal surface. Tension requirements are summarized in the table below; the allowed tolerance on nominal tension is ±5%. On temperature, the reference and the device under test shall be allowed to stabilize at the reference temperature, usually 68°F (20°C); this temperature shall be maintained and recorded, and a determination of whether a correction for ambient temperature is necessary shall be based on the calibration accuracy required.
| Tape Length | Applied Tension | Conversion |
|---|---|---|
| Up to 100 feet (30 m) | 10 lb | Approx. 45 N |
| Over 100 feet (30 m) | 20 lb | Approx. 90 N |
| Tension tolerance | ±5% of nominal | — |
Temperature effects are not to be underestimated: the coefficient of linear thermal expansion of steel is approximately 6.38×10⁻⁶ m/(m·°C), so a 100-foot (30.5 m) steel tape drifts about 0.00765 inch per degree Fahrenheit (≈0.35 mm/°C) from the reference operating temperature; for brass the error is at least 50 percent larger, depending on the type of brass. For high-accuracy calibrations, temperature stabilization and correction are therefore essential.
4. Test Procedure and Presentation of Results 🧪
For linear scale devices, the procedure is: select at least five points approximately equally spaced over the range of the device to be calibrated; align the device datum with the calibration reference and, using the reference, measure and record the distance to each data point; each measurement shall be made with a precision of ten times the accuracy required for the device being calibrated. For non-linear or expanded scale devices (e.g., tapes reading volume directly, or rules inserted at an angle), first perform the same point selection, then transform the scale to a linear scale by applying the appropriate geometry or original design data, and finally perform the comparisons using the transformed scale. Typical worked examples in the Standard include the volume-versus-height relation for a hemispherical tank of radius r, and an inclined sounding rule in a tank of constant horizontal cross-section, where the level height h relates to the scale reading a by h = a·cosθ.
For presentation of results, tabulate the difference between each recorded value and the corresponding true value; this difference is the error, which may be expressed either as a percentage of total length or in scale units. A negative error denotes that the observed value is greater than the true value. From this tabulation the Reference Accuracy is determined — it is the limit that errors will not exceed when the device is used at the reference operating temperature, taken as the greatest positive or negative error of any recorded value. Reference Accuracy may be expressed in any of the following forms: in terms of the measured variable; as a percentage of span; as a percentage of upper range-value; as a percentage of scale length; or as a percentage of actual reading — with the units being used stated explicitly. The Standard’s example is a 50-foot tape with a maximum error of 0.02 foot, where each foot is equivalent to 1000 gallons: its Reference Accuracy may be expressed as ±0.02 foot, ±20 gallons, or ±0.04% of scale length.
✅ The Standard provides a standard Calibration Report form (Figure 1) tabulating test number, date, description, manufacturer, model, serial number, range, scale characteristic, calibration reference standard details, temperature, tape tension, and the point-by-point readings and errors — ideal for archiving and traceability.
5. Engineering Practice Essentials 🛠️
- 🔍 Tension control: calibrate and use the tape under consistent, documented tension; exceeding the ±5% tolerance introduces significant length error directly.
- 🌡️ Temperature management: steel and brass expand at markedly different rates; long tapes require temperature stabilization and correction, ideally with a temperature-error correction table.
- 📊 Test-point selection: use at least five equally spaced points across the full range, including end regions; transform non-linear scales geometrically before comparison to avoid systematic reading bias.
- 📋 Traceability: send the calibration reference to a higher-echelon metrology laboratory periodically, keep its certificate, and record its last-calibration date and accuracy on every report to keep the measurement chain complete.
6. Frequently Asked Questions ❓
❓ Q: Why must the reference accuracy be at least 3 times, preferably 10 times, that of the tape under test?
A: This is a metrological compromise that keeps the reference error negligible in the calibration result. At 10× better accuracy the reference uncertainty can ordinarily be ignored; when it is less than 10×, the reference’s own uncertainty must be combined into the calibration result.
A: This is a metrological compromise that keeps the reference error negligible in the calibration result. At 10× better accuracy the reference uncertainty can ordinarily be ignored; when it is less than 10×, the reference’s own uncertainty must be combined into the calibration result.
❓ Q: Why do tapes over 100 feet need a higher applied tension?
A: Under its own weight and coiled condition a tape sags and deforms, much more so for long tapes. The higher tension (20 lb) keeps the tape close to the straightness of its intended use, reducing sag-induced reading errors; tension should also match field measuring practice as closely as possible.
A: Under its own weight and coiled condition a tape sags and deforms, much more so for long tapes. The higher tension (20 lb) keeps the tape close to the straightness of its intended use, reducing sag-induced reading errors; tension should also match field measuring practice as closely as possible.
❓ Q: How are non-linear scales (e.g., volume-direct-reading tapes) calibrated?
A: Select test points as for linear devices, then use geometry or original design data (such as the hemispherical-tank volume formula or the inclined-rule relation h = a·cosθ) to transform the scale to a linear one, and perform the comparisons against the reference on the transformed scale.
A: Select test points as for linear devices, then use geometry or original design data (such as the hemispherical-tank volume formula or the inclined-rule relation h = a·cosθ) to transform the scale to a linear one, and perform the comparisons against the reference on the transformed scale.
🔍 Q: How should a “negative error” in the report be interpreted?
A: The error is defined as the recorded (observed) value minus the true value. A negative error means the observed value is greater than the true value — the tape reads high. Reference Accuracy is the greatest error magnitude among all recorded values and defines the limit the device does not exceed at the reference operating temperature.
A: The error is defined as the recorded (observed) value minus the true value. A negative error means the observed value is greater than the true value — the tape reads high. Reference Accuracy is the greatest error magnitude among all recorded values and defines the limit the device does not exceed at the reference operating temperature.
